August 20, 2024

The Pay for Play News Networks


In August of 2020, the New York Times reported on a network of nearly 1,300 websites which the Times stated were filling a void left by vanishing local newspapers across the country. The Times reported that “many of their stories are ordered up by conservative political groups and corporate P.R. firms.”  Almost all of these “local papers” in California are still in existence today.

For example, the following headline and photo appeared in the South Bay Leader South Bay Leader on August 5, 2024:Fake News Headline

The same headline, changing out Representative Lieu’s name and photo with the local Democratic Congressperson’s name and photo, appeared in several “local” digital papers on August 5, 2024.

There are still almost 80 “local” news sites in California that are actually part of a propaganda network driven by Republican operatives, corporate P.R. firms and dark money. As the Times, the Columbia Journalism School’s Tow Center, the GuardianMichigan Daily, and the Lansing State Journal independently reported, the content on these sites is largely determined by political operatives who are clients of this “pay-for-play” network. As The Wrap reported, this network pays freelance writers to promote Republican candidates, focus on conservative topics, and attack Democratic opponents, “often without journalistic due diligence, transparency and fairness.” The remainder of the content was found to be “algorithmically generated using publicly available data sets or by repurposing stories from legitimate sources.”  For example, on August 5, 2024, the headlines in several of these “local papers,” each ran an article with the Democratic Representative from that particular district pictured and the headline, U.S. Rep. (X) votes to make it easier for illegal aliens to vote in federal elections.

Here are the papers still published in California that were found by the Times to be “pay to play”:

Antelope Valley Today

California Business Daily

Central Alameda News

Central OC Times

Chico Times

Coachella Today

East Alameda News

East Contra Costa News

East San Diego News

East SBV Times

East SFV Today

East Sierra News

East Ventura News

Fresno Leader

Golden State Today

Imperial CA News

Kern County Times

Kings County Times

LA Harbor News

Lake Tahoe Sun

LAX Leader

Madison – St. Clair Record

Marin Leader

Merced Times

Monterey Times

NE Cali News

NE Sacramento News

North Coast California News

North Inland News

North OC Times

North Sacramento Today

North SFV Today

North SGV News

Northern California Record

NW LA Times

NW Riverside News

Oakland Record

Pomona Valley News

Redding Today
Redwood Empire News

Sacramento Standard

San Diego Record

San Francisco Sun

San Joaquin Times

San Jose Standard

San Mateo Sun

Santa Clara Today

Santa Cruz Standard

SE LA Times

SFV Today

SGV Standard

SLO Reporter

Solano Sun

South Alameda News

South Bay Leader

South Bay SD News

South OC Times

South Sacramento Today

South SF Bay News

South SFV Today

South SGV News

Southern California Record

Stanislaus News

SW Riverside News

Tulare Times

Verdugos News

Victor Valley Times

West Contra Costa News

West El Dorado News

West LA Times

West OC Times

West SBV Times

West SFV Today

West SGV News

West Ventura News

Wine Country Times

Yuba-Sutter Times

Sources:

These California 'Local Papers' Are Part of a Shadowy Conservative Pay-for-Play Network - TheWrap

Here Are the Hundreds of Sites in a Pay-to-Play Local News Network - The New York Times (nytimes.com)